The covers of Surrounded by Idiots and Surrounded by Psychopaths by Thomas Erikson side by side

Surrounded by Idiots vs Surrounded by Psychopaths: What to Read First

Read Surrounded by Idiots first. Almost everyone should. The only reason to start with the other one is that you already have a name in mind, one person who keeps taking credit for your work, and you have started to wonder about them.

Both books are by Thomas Erikson and both use the same four colours. The difference is who they are about.

Surrounded by Idiots is about people who are difficult by accident. They are not trying to hurt you. They are Red and you are Blue, or the other way round, and neither of you has noticed.

Surrounded by Psychopaths is about people who are difficult on purpose. The charm has a job. Erikson published it a year later, in October 2020, and it is the shorter book at 272 pages against 304.

How the 2 books differ

The first book is a map of the office. The second is a warning about a few people standing on it. They differ on length, on what each colour is used to show, and on what you do the week after finishing.

Surrounded by IdiotsSurrounded by Psychopaths
Published in English30 July 20196 October 2020
Length304 pages272 pages
What it is forSending a message that the other person can receiveSpotting manipulation early and protecting yourself from it
The modelThe four colours, red, yellow, green and blueThe same four colours, used to show how each one gets exploited
What you do after readingRewrite your briefs, agendas and follow-upsSet a boundary, get things in writing, keep a record
Best forAnyone who runs reviews, clients or a teamAnyone who has a charming colleague and a bad feeling

What Surrounded by Idiots does for you

The first book is the one I go back to. It assumes everyone in the room is trying to get the work done, and the problem is the format of the message. That assumption is true most of the time, which is why the advice keeps working after the novelty wears off.

What I still use from it is the two-version habit. Before a review, I write the same point twice, once with the headline first for the person who decides, once with the reasoning first for the person who checks. It takes four minutes and it has cut my follow-up threads down to one exchange.

What Surrounded by Psychopaths does for you

The second book starts from a worse place. Some colleagues are not confused, they are managing you, and the four colours become a list of ways each type gets taken advantage of. The publisher’s description promises how to identify the manipulators early, how to set boundaries, and how to keep your emotional energy. That is roughly what the book delivers.

The useful part for me was the language. Charm, flattery, a sudden ally in a meeting, a request for a favour that arrives right after a compliment. Once you have names for the sequence, you notice it while it is happening instead of three months later.

Where the second book is weaker

The word psychopath is a clinical term and Erikson is a behaviourist, not a clinician, so in my reading it is doing the work of a behaviour pattern rather than a diagnosis. That matters in an Indian office where a difficult manager gets called a psychopath in the pantry and the word travels to somebody’s appraisal.

The other weakness is inherited. Both books run on the four colours, and the research position on DISC does not change between them. If you are going to use either book, use it as a set of questions about behaviour rather than a verdict on a person. DISC does not hold up under testing, which is why that line is not optional.

The problem decides which book to start with

  1. You keep getting blank replies and rewritten briefs. Read Surrounded by Idiots. Your problem is format, not malice.
  2. You are managing a team for the first time. Read Surrounded by Idiots, then keep it on the desk for a quarter before buying the second one.
  3. One person keeps taking credit, and your manager believes them. Go straight to Surrounded by Psychopaths. The colour chapter will still be there when you come back.
  4. You want one book for a book club. Surrounded by Idiots. It starts better arguments about work and it has a title that sells itself.

Neither book made me better at reading people

I read Surrounded by Idiots first and got more out of it. Surrounded by Psychopaths was useful in a narrower way, on two occasions involving a client contact who was very warm in meetings and very quiet on email when a payment was due. Neither book made me better at reading people. They made me better at writing things down at the right time.

If you only read one, take the first. It applies to every desk in the building, and the second only applies to a handful. The 5-point summary of Surrounded by Idiots covers the first book in less time than a commute. The two-version habit is the one change from it that stuck, and dealing with a difficult colleague is where it earns its keep. For the lighter version of the same decision, picking a book by mood takes two minutes. More book arguments sit in Book Notes.

2 thoughts on “Surrounded by Idiots vs Surrounded by Psychopaths: What to Read First”

  1. Pingback: Surrounded by Idiots: What Thomas Erikson Says in 5 Points - Siddharth Vira

  2. Pingback: 7 Things Surrounded by Idiots Teaches About Difficult Colleagues - Siddharth Vira

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top