Employees working at desks in an Indian office while a manager stands nearby

7 Things Surrounded by Idiots Teaches About Difficult Colleagues

Surrounded by Idiots starts from a real sentence. Thomas Erikson was talking to a chief executive who said he was surrounded by idiots, and the whole book is the answer to that sentence. The answer is that most of the people you call idiots are not idiots. They communicate in a way that does not fit yours.

That is the useful core. Everything else in the book is a system for seeing the difference, the four colours, before it costs you a working relationship. Each of the 7 lessons is checked against what other readers and reviewers say about the book.

7 things the book teaches about difficult colleagues

  1. The idiot is usually a format problem. Erikson’s point is that behaviour is a style, not a defect. A reader on Reddit put it the bluntest way: people are not idiots, they just do not know how to communicate with each other. The person you find impossible in a meeting is often fine with a written brief, or the reverse. The book does not fix them. It changes what you send.
  2. Self-awareness comes before reading other people. The interviews around the book keep returning to this. Erikson says the method only works if you start with yourself, because you cannot read a colour you have not seen in your own behaviour. One review put it simply: the primary takeaway is self-awareness, and understanding what motivates the other person.
  3. Red and Green clash on speed, not on right and wrong. This is the most practical line in the book, and Erikson said it plainly in an interview: reds have to slow down and consider that greens are relation-oriented, and greens have to speed up and realise that reds are not. Neither is wrong. They are optimising for different things, and most office arguments are that gap wearing a disguise.
  4. Give people the format they need, not the one that is fastest for you. A direct person wants the ask in the first line. A relation-oriented person wants a greeting and some context first. Sending the wrong format is not a small thing. It is the single most common reason a correct message lands badly, and it is the part of the book that applies to email more than any other.
  5. People react out of habit, and they do not always see it. One careful review of the book makes this point well: people react out of habit, a habit they may not recognise or accept in themselves. That is why pointing at the four colours at someone rarely works. You do not tell a colleague they are a Red. You adjust your own message and let the habit meet a better format.
  6. The labels are thinner than they look. This is where the book’s critics are right, and the criticism is worth reading before you recommend it. A reviewer noted that people with ADHD showed Red and Yellow qualities too, and a Reddit thread from a workplace that made staff read it called the whole model pseudoscience. The four colours are a starting map, not a diagnosis, and using them to sort real people will backfire.
  7. It will not fix the other person. The book is about what you can change, which is your half. If you read it hoping the difficult person becomes easy, you will be disappointed. If you read it to make your own messages shorter, clearer and easier to receive, it pays for itself quickly.

Where the book’s critics are right

The title annoys people, and so does the method. The strongest criticism, and it is fair, is that the science behind DISC is thin, that the four boxes flatten real people, and that neurodivergence is left out entirely. None of that stops the book being useful as a communication manual.

The summary of Surrounded by Idiots carries the book’s 5 claims in a page, and what the 4 colours mean at work is the faster version of the model. If the colleague is manipulative rather than merely difficult, the comparison with Surrounded by Psychopaths is the better read. If the choice in front of you is the next book rather than this one, how to choose what to read next sets out a method for it. More book-note arguments sit in Book Notes.

1 thought on “7 Things Surrounded by Idiots Teaches About Difficult Colleagues”

  1. Pingback: The Courage to Be Disliked Says a Client's Decision Is Not Yours to Carry - Siddharth Vira

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top