I have read Surrounded by Idiots twice and still hand it to people. It gets three things wrong. It sells a training-room model as a personality test, it invites you to label people who cannot answer back, and it rests on workshop experience rather than published research. I still recommend it. None of the three stopped the book giving me a vocabulary that a research paper never would.
The pop-psychology problem
The four colours are a simplified DISC, and DISC does not hold up under testing. Wikipedia’s entry describes DISC assessments as pseudoscientific, with validity that has not been demonstrated. A 2013 German review of one DISC instrument, Persolog, found it largely met reliability standards and did not meet validity standards at all. A study in the Scandinavian Journal of Psychology found the four dimensions were not independent and fitted better as combinations of the Big Five traits.
None of that is in the book in any form a reader can check. The authority behind the method is decades of seminar work, which is what the publisher’s author note cites. That is a real source of insight about people and a weak source of proof about them, and the book does not always keep the difference visible.
The labelling problem
The bigger risk is what happens after you finish the book. You get a label for every person you find annoying, and the label explains all of their behaviour, which is exactly what makes it useless. A model that explains everything you see predicts nothing you can test. The same thing happens with the 17 categories Barnes & Noble split its best books into, which say more about what a shop can sell than about the year.
I did this with a colleague I decided was yellow. His lateness became a yellow thing, his missed follow-ups became a yellow thing, and by the third month I had stopped noticing the weeks when he was the most reliable person in the room. The label was doing the looking for me.
The fix is a question I now ask about every guess. What would I see this week that would prove me wrong? If nothing could, I am not reading a person, I am defending a story about them.
The missing research base
Swedish reviewers were blunt about this long before the English edition arrived. Mattias Lundberg, an associate professor of psychology at UmeƄ University, told Sydsvenskan in January 2019 that the book was nonsense, in a piece whose headline used the same word. In the same month, the Swedish Skeptics association, Vetenskap och Folkbildning, gave Erikson its ironic Bewilderer of the Year award for 2018. The citation listed the book as teaching people to divide others into four types on a theory with no scientific support.
That is a hard verdict from people who test claims for a living. It is also a verdict about the theory rather than the reader. The colour framework can still help you write a clearer email to a busy person, even though the theory behind it is shaky.
What it does well
- It moves the question from the other person’s character to your own delivery, which is the only part you control.
- It gives four names and four formats, which is enough for a team to have a shared word for something they already felt.
- It is short and readable. The English edition runs 304 pages, which is a weekend of reading.
- The title is honest about the experience it describes, the meeting where nobody understood you, and Erikson has said plainly that he is not calling anyone an idiot.
The book earns its place with 2 rules attached
I recommend it with two rules attached. First, use a colour as a question and never as a conclusion. Blue is a hypothesis about how someone wants a message, and the next meeting is allowed to overrule it. Second, never apply the model to someone who cannot answer back. Colouring a report in an appraisal, or a candidate in an interview, turns a communication aid into a decision that the person has no way to challenge.
The strongest argument for the book is a practical one. In an Indian office you will meet the four patterns in a single morning, and most people have no shared language for why the same message lands differently on two desks. The book supplies that language in a weekend. The research will not tell you what to write in the first line of the email.
The summary is the short version of the same book, the 4 colours keep the caveat attached to each type, and the comparison with Surrounded by Psychopaths is where the model gets stretched furthest. More book arguments sit in Book Notes.








Pingback: Surrounded by Idiots vs Surrounded by Psychopaths: Which to Read First - Siddharth Vira
Pingback: Surrounded by Idiots: What Thomas Erikson Actually Says - Siddharth Vira