3 Questions the Show Has to Answer Before 25 December

Three things about this adaptation are still unknown, and they will decide whether it works. HBO has confirmed the date, the cast, the composer and one scene. It has not answered the three questions below, and the first episode will answer all of them whether it means to or not.

1. Does it keep Harry’s point of view, or widen it?

The clip already chose. John Lithgow as Dumbledore and Janet McTeer as McGonagall have a private conversation about Harry at the staff table, and he is not in earshot. That scene is not in the book, and the reaction to it was the most divided part of the release. Widening the camera is the one thing a series can do that a 2001 film with two hours could not, and it is also the fastest way to make a children’s story feel like a drama about adults.

2. How much of the film’s look does it keep?

The Great Hall in the clip is recognisably the Great Hall from the films, and the robes are the robes. That is a commercial decision as much as an artistic one, because the audience for this show is people who already have the films in their heads. The risk is not change, it is a remake that looks like a tribute.

3. Does the score quote John Williams or avoid him?

Hans Zimmer and Bleeding Fingers are writing new music, with Kara Talve and Anze Rozman named alongside him. MuggleNet listened to the clip and described sweeping strings, flutes and full orchestral flourishes, and called the result familiar. Familiar is the word to watch. A score that quotes the Williams theme will make people cheer and will also make the show feel like a cover version.

What is already fixed

  • Premiere: 25 December 2026, HBO and HBO Max
  • Harry: Dominic McLaughlin. Ron: Alastair Stout. Hermione: Arabella Stanton
  • Dumbledore: John Lithgow. McGonagall: Janet McTeer. Snape: Paapa Essiedu. Hagrid: Nick Frost
  • Showrunner: Francesca Gardiner. Mark Mylod directs multiple episodes

None of these three questions has a public answer. If you want to know how the show is being positioned before it airs, the answer is in the score and the running time of episode one, not in the casting.

Image via HBO

Also read:

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top